Events & Lifestyle

REVIEW: The Magic Puzzle Company (Spoiler Alert)

Back in Spring of 2020, I backed my first-ever Kickstarter project: a trio of “Magic Puzzles” by The Magic Puzzle Company, brought to you by the co-founder of Cards Against Humanity, Max Temkin.

Being that 2020 was the year of staying at home, it seemed like the perfect time to invest in something like this. Clearly, I wasn’t the only one who felt that way. The project was backed by 62,000 people. In total, over $3.4 million was raised to fund the creation of these puzzles! I am not a puzzler. In fact, I’ve never sat down to do a full puzzle, much less a 1,000-piece one. But everything about this project, from the name of the company, and the thoughtful details that indicated that this was not your average puzzle, intrigued me.

The Magic Puzzle Company Review

Three puzzles are all original artwork, commissioned by independent artists and designed from the very beginning to be used in a jigsaw puzzle. There were three 1000-piece puzzles in the set:

  1. Magic Puzzle Company “The Mystic Maze” by Boya Sun
  2. Magic Puzzle Company “The Sunny City” by Felicia Chiao
  3. Magic Puzzle Company “The Happy Isles” by Sarah Becan

Each puzzle has so much detail, it feels like you’re also playing Where’s Waldo as you’re hunting for pieces. “Easter Eggs” are hidden within each puzzle, and there’s a checklist of things to look for in each puzzle—a cat inside a bubble, a barrel full of fish—as you work towards completing it. Each puzzle is custom cut in a way to maximize the details within each individual piece, highlighting the cool art details, instead of cutting them in half.

Magic Puzzle Company

Most intriguing of all, however, is the “magical surprise” ending included in each puzzle. As you can imagine, there were a lot of questions via Kickstarter on what this ending is. I was amused by the cheeky answer The Magic Puzzle Company gave in response to some of the “wild theories” they were receiving.

It’s basically an optical illusion and a neat surprise at the end. If you think the puzzle is going to fold itself into a robot and walk about the room you are setting yourself up for disappointment. Please remember it costs $20 and is made of recycled cardboard.

They also clarified that the ending doesn’t involve electronics or technology, and it not one of those ‘3D magic eye’ illusions either.

The Mystic Maze puzzle explained: what’s the surprise ending? [Spoiler Alert]

The puzzle we opened was The Mystic Maze (we’re saving the other two as gifts) and the loose storyline of that puzzle is that the heroine—a girl in a yellow rainjacket—is looking for her lost friend. The puzzle artwork has the girl searching through different rooms and mystical worlds, from outer space to a whimsical forest.

The Mystic Maze Magic Puzzle Company

The Mystic Maze (before the surprise ending)

When you’re finished the puzzle, there’s an envelope with additional puzzle pieces and instructions on what to do next. Basically, the puzzle comes apart in three pieces, and are then rearranged so that a space appears in the middle. Even after rearranging the pieces, the artwork is still continuous! There’s probably another 50 puzzle pieces in the envelope, and upon completing the puzzle within the newly-formed space, the heroine is reunited with her friend.

So I wouldn’t say it’s magical, but it was definitely cool, wholesome, and heartwarming.

Overall, we really enjoyed our first puzzle experience but I’m afraid that we’ve entered the puzzling world now with high expectations and I’ll never be able to do a ‘regular’ non-magical puzzle again.

Where to Buy Magic Puzzle Company

Initially you could only buy Magic Puzzle Company through Kickstarter, but recently I found it on Amazon Canada. As an Amazon Affiliate, if you buy from clicking the links shared in the post, I may get a small commission from the sale.

12 Comments

  1. Maureen Caron
    February 20, 2021 at 10:24 am — Reply

    My sister heard about the Kickstarter and invested in it. She handed out the puzzles at Christmas. We did the first and loved the surprise ending and the where’s Waldo checklist. Then passed it on to another family member until we did all three. No puzzle dist, very unique pieces and great fun. Artist work is excellent as well. Would definitely buy more puzzles.

    • February 20, 2021 at 8:46 pm — Reply

      So glad to hear you’re enjoying the puzzles, thanks for the comment!

  2. Gemberly
    June 25, 2021 at 6:36 am — Reply

    I finished the puzzle and was missing a piece. Does anyone know how I contact them?

  3. Dan Moss
    November 10, 2021 at 4:23 pm — Reply

    /Users/danmoss 1/Desktop/IMG_1696.jpeg/Users/danmoss 1/Desktop/IMG_1699.jpeg
    Loved all three of your mystery puzzles. We lost a piece and hope we can get a replacement.
    Thank you
    Dan Moss
    6931 Church Circle
    Huntington Beach, CA. 92648

    • November 11, 2021 at 3:47 pm — Reply

      Hi Dan, I’m not associated with The Magic Puzzle company, just a customer who wrote a review.
      You can try emailing: info@magicpuzzlecompany.com to get in touch with them. Hope you can get your piece replaced!

  4. I mccann
    March 10, 2022 at 11:58 am — Reply

    Loved the puzzle however I was missing a piece

    • March 20, 2022 at 3:06 pm — Reply

      Hi there! I’m not associated with The Magic Puzzle company, just a customer who wrote a review. You can try emailing: info@magicpuzzlecompany.com to get in touch with them. Hope you can get your piece replaced!

  5. Mary Ellrodt
    May 8, 2022 at 1:21 pm — Reply

    Loved the puzzle “the mystic maze”!
    The artwork, the too many flat edge pieces conundrum!! The artwork and the ending illusion, the fun Manila envelopes within envelopes.

    The only thing I don’t get is finding the Easter eggs?
    What do these look like and how many are there? I dont see any???!

    Big Puzzler Fan

  6. Mary Ellrodt
    May 8, 2022 at 1:23 pm — Reply

    What do the Easter eggs look like? and how many are there? these are the only things I can’t find in the mystic maze puzzle.

    Big puzzler Fan

  7. mike mieszala
    July 2, 2022 at 10:04 am — Reply

    just built the statue of liberty 22 pieces. if anyone does a 1000 pieces puzzle you are a masochist. waste of time looks like crap don’t know why anyone does stuff like this The next time my grandson gets one as a gift and asks for help i’ll take him to the movies instead. i’ll bet walmart doesn’t sell junk like this in their stores

  8. Lyn Erickson
    July 9, 2022 at 7:41 pm — Reply

    I also was a first time backer for this Kickstarter project and we just finished completing a second one. (We are snowbirds and the puzzles were delivered to our Washington address just after left for Arizona last year.) We so enjoyed these first two – the last one is the one with lots of blue water… not so sure we are as excited to do that. We really loved the small details in the first two.

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *